Same Day Sharpening

Alright folks this is it. Which one is best?
One of these hand-drawn logos from Cam at Left Hand Signs will become my new logo.

I told Cam that I'm looking for something that is simple. The best logos are the simplist ones. If it's too busy it's confusing. Our minds are naturally drawn to simplicity. Further simplicity is a guiding North Star of my business.

I also wanted it to look authentic. Imagine these on the side of a 1950s van. Too many colors, shading, etc wouldn't be authentic to the brand.

It's also important that it looks friendly and safe, for obvious reasons. I'm a friendly neighborhood soon sharpening service, not a heavy metal band

Bonus points if my 3 year old daughter can look at the logo and recognize me!