Instagram story viewer> @thejohnnatale> Post
13 days ago
Co Creator: thegalleyap
74
Posted On: October 24th 2026, 11:15 am
Tagged Users:
Is this Pizza Spot with a DEEP MENU One of the Best at the Jersey Shore? 🍕

Is It Legit? with Jersey John ☑️

Today guys, we’re checking out The Galley Pizza & Eatery

Is It Legit is a simple concept. No scores. No ratings. Just is a spot legit and worth your time and money to check out. I’m not paid by the establishment, I pay for my food and tip the wait staff.

Here’s my breakdown:
The Atmosphere: Not a huge spot however an absolutely on-point vibe. It’s rugged but simple inside. The pizza station is open to the restaurant. There’s an energy inside and out at the Galley. It almost feels like a (clean) dive you expect to get greatness from. Fits right into Asbury Park, especially the northwest section. Legit ☑️

The Service: The whole staff here embodies Asbury Park. It seems like there’s a lot of personalities and depending when you go and who’s there, the experience will be different. I mean that in a great way. The service is efficient and welcoming. Almost one of those you have to experience to understand. Carmine’s the man. Legit ☑️

The Food: This is one of the most recommended places I get for Is It Legit. The menu literally reads like a diner menu. The fact that everything from the sauces and dishes are scratch made is borderline insane. They do everything in house here. And you can tell. Legit ☑️

Recommendation: I genuinely mean this. You need to try exactly what I tried. The buffalo wings. The double smash. The Philly cooper. Round pie (Badlands was 🔥) and a Detroit pie (General was unbelievable).

The Galley is Legit ☑️
1313 Memorial Drive, Asbury Park NJ 07712
Open: Wed - Sat 12PM - 9PM Sun 12PM - 8PM, closed Mon-Tue

Check em out and let em know Jersey John sent ya!

#newjersey #jerseyshore #pizza #cheesesteak#monmouthcounty
Comments (74)
barlepine 10 days ago

barlepine

Obsessed with The Galley! A MUST try is their Chicken Parm Vodka sub - it’s on garlic bread and it’s one of the best things, with the Bell and Evans chicken, that you’ll ever taste in your life… and it’s huge!

phyltartaglia 10 days ago

phyltartaglia

❤️❤️

helenetaylorphotography 10 days ago

helenetaylorphotography

Woah!!! The food is fantastic!!

theflyingpigmarket 10 days ago

theflyingpigmarket

Soooo damn good 🤤

yojrod182 11 days ago

yojrod182

@jerseywingwars

harlempaige 11 days ago

harlempaige

Love the galley🔥🔥❤️

trailmixsnl 11 days ago

trailmixsnl

We moved 5 years ago and besides missing our friends, THE GALLEY IS THE BEST , they just go farther than any other place we've ever eaten at. I'm in Florida and can say, if your up near this place, get their NOW. We miss it beyond belief!!!!!!!!!

jjjj_ames 12 days ago

jjjj_ames

Best in NJ

names_kaleea 12 days ago

names_kaleea

Live there I never heard of them

dv1225 12 days ago

dv1225

We love it there!

back.wardswego 12 days ago

back.wardswego

About time. @pizzaps1to8 knows pizza. This place is pizza !!!!

Load More

More posts

back to up