Instagram story viewer> @thejohnnatale> Post
5 days ago
155
Posted On: October 31st 2026, 11:15 am
Is the Seafood from this Monmouth County Fishery Worth ATTACKING Jersey John Over? 🍤

Is It Legit? with Jersey John ☑️

Today guys, we’re checking out Keyport Fishery.

Is It Legit is a simple concept. No scores. No ratings. Just is a spot legit and worth your time and money to check out. I’m not paid by the establishment, I pay for my food and tip the wait staff.

Here’s my breakdown:
The Atmosphere: Old school, and I mean old school fish market here. There’s a raw fish section to the left and you order tucked into the corner on the right. You’re sitting on a creek and across the street is the bay and marina. If you want real life rustic fishery, this is the spot for you. Legit ☑️

The Service: The gentleman at the counter, even right after they opened, was direct but helpful with what to order. You pay cash and then wait for your initials to be called. More or less Legit ☑️

The Food: I’ve heard from family members to check this spot out, and after featuring a couple of other Keyport businesses I got quite a few comments and DMs to check it out. Even though I’m not really a “huge” seafood guy, fried fish is my jam though. The fish here is not covered in tons of batter. After all this seafood, it was heavy on my stomach however I ate a bunch. Since the batter isn’t too heavy, if you like salt, you’ll want to add. The fries are crisp. The slaw was great. It was $53 for all this food. Legit ☑️

Recommendation: Get the combination platter. Great way to sample a few different fishes. I’d suggest going out to the park across the street however don’t let a piece of food fall off your plate if birds are around. That was INSANE!

Keyport Fishery is Legit ☑️
150 W Front Street, Keyport NJ 07735
Open: Sun, Tues-Thurs 9AM-7PM, Fri-Sat 9AM-8PM, closed Mo. Food starts at 11.

Check em out and let em know Jersey John sent ya!

#newjersey #jerseyshore #monmouthcounty #seafood #fish
Comments (155)
klbutler24 12 hours ago

klbutler24

The best seafood, I’ve been going there for 50 years!

joannejoei 13 hours ago

joannejoei

🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌

mommahue 14 hours ago

mommahue

The Best !!

kjmarr13 a day ago

kjmarr13

👍🙏👍🙏

timhitchings a day ago

timhitchings

My go-to for whole belly fried clams

africa_9878 2 days ago

africa_9878

Damn it the lines already be long as hell 😂. The Keyport Fishery is awesome 🔥

davebasselini 2 days ago

davebasselini

Scallop sandwich on white bread i would have thrown it in garbage

donnamedell 3 days ago

donnamedell

Yum!!!

raeanneguzzi 3 days ago

raeanneguzzi

Love Keyport Fishery!

vallegirl147 3 days ago

vallegirl147

The best!!!

patricefealy_ 3 days ago

patricefealy_

Thank you’re telling me about this place. looks so delicious. They will have a new customer.

ashley_24_14 3 days ago

ashley_24_14

We went yesterday cuz we live so close

Load More

More posts

back to up